The CoinsNearMe directory lists 7 coin shops and dealers in Indianapolis, Indiana, each with a verified address and Google reviews or a website. The top-rated, JML Coin & Jewelry Estate Buyers ( by appointment ), holds 4.7 stars across 80 Google reviews. Of the 7, 2 trade gold and silver bullion.
Visiting a coin shop in Indianapolis? Check 12 things before you buy: free Coin Buyer’s Playbook.
PDF, downloads right away. You’ll also get the CoinsCollx daily email. One click to unsubscribe.
This guide ranks the best-rated of them by Google review score, with a review floor so a shop with three perfect reviews can't outrank one with three hundred. For every shop in the city, with hours, phone numbers and services, see the Indianapolis coin shop directory.
Best-rated coin shops in Indianapolis
Ranked by Google rating, then number of reviews. Ratings come from Google Maps; open any shop for current hours.
1. JML Coin & Jewelry Estate Buyers ( by appointment )
A 4.7-star rating from 80 Google reviews. The shop on Keystone Crossing buys and sells coins and carries U.S. coins. Hours, phone and directions »
2. Lost Dutchman Rare Coins
A 4.6-star rating from 149 Google reviews. The shop on North Franklin Road buys and sells coins and stocks world and ancient coins. Hours, phone and directions »
3. Midwest Jewelry and Bullion
A 4.4-star rating from 106 Google reviews. This dealer on East 96th Street buys and sells coins, trades gold and silver bullion and carries U.S. coins. Hours, phone and directions »
4. Cash Exchange Antiques & More
124 Google reviews averaging 4.1 stars. The shop on West Washington Street buys and sells coins and carries U.S. coins. Hours, phone and directions »
5. a James Jewelry & Coin
A 4.1-star rating from 28 Google reviews. This dealer on East 62nd Street buys and sells coins. Hours, phone and directions »
Selling coins in Indianapolis? Our guide to selling coins in Indianapolis covers how to get a fair price, what to bring, and how to handle an inherited collection.
More coin shops in Indianapolis
Also in the Indianapolis directory, by number of Google reviews:
How to choose a coin shop in Indianapolis
Match the shop to the job. Buying bullion: compare the premium over spot on the same coin or bar at two or three shops; it varies more than people expect. 2 of the Indianapolis shops list bullion. Collecting U.S. or world coins: look for a dealer whose case matches what you collect, and ask whether they can find coins for you.
Selling: get an appraisal first, never clean a coin before showing it, and get more than one offer for anything valuable. Grading: you don't need your own PCGS or NGC account; an authorized dealer can submit coins for you.
Coin shows near Indianapolis
Coin shows put dozens of dealers in one room, which makes them the fastest way to compare prices. See upcoming coin shows in Indiana.
See all 7 shops: the Indianapolis coin shop directory has every listing with addresses, hours and services.
Frequently asked questions
How many coin shops are in Indianapolis?
The CoinsNearMe directory lists 7 coin shops and dealers in Indianapolis with a verified address and Google reviews or a website. The full list is on the Indianapolis directory page.
What is the best-rated coin shop in Indianapolis?
JML Coin & Jewelry Estate Buyers ( by appointment ) is the top-rated coin shop in Indianapolis in this guide, with 4.7 stars across 80 Google reviews.
Where can I get coins appraised in Indianapolis?
Most coin shops in Indianapolis will look at a coin or a collection and tell you what they would pay. Call ahead to ask about formal appraisals and fees.
Do Indianapolis coin shops buy gold and silver?
Yes. 2 shops in Indianapolis list gold and silver bullion. Compare offers against the day's spot price, and ask what share of spot each shop pays.
Buying or selling coins? Start here
Straight answers to the questions collectors ask most, with numbers you can check.
- What Is the Best Place to Sell Coins Online in 2026?
- Is It Worth Getting My Coin Graded?
- I Inherited a Coin Collection. What Should I Do First?
- Is This a Fair Price for My Coin?
Want all of it in one place? Buying and Selling Coins: The 2026 Guide