Home › Blog › What Percentage of Melt or Retail Do Coin Dealers Pay?
What Percentage of Melt or Retail Do Coin Dealers Pay?
The short answer
Dealers pay for bullion by the metal and for collectible coins by the retail price. Posted dealer bids on September 2, 2026 ran 93–99% of spot for a 1 oz Gold Eagle, 84–95% for Silver Eagles and 65–89% of melt for 90% junk silver.
On collectible coins, local shops typically pay 50–80% of retail, and specialist rare-coin dealers reportedly pay 75–90% of fair market value.
Do coin dealers pay a percentage of melt or a percentage of retail?
It depends on which of three buckets the coin falls into. The dealer sorts it before he names a number, so you should sort it first.
- Bullion. Modern rounds and bars, common-date American Silver Eagles, generic pre-1933 gold and junk silver. These trade at spot plus a premium, so a dealer’s bid is a percentage of spot or melt. You price them by checking spot that day, not by opening a coin guide.
- Numismatic. Key dates, high-grade certified coins, varieties, strong toners and scarce types. These trade on collector demand, and the metal barely matters. An 1893-S Morgan’s silver is a rounding error against its value. The dealer’s bid is a percentage of retail.
- The overlap zone. Common-date Morgans, circulated classic gold and mid-grade silver type coins. The metal value and the collector value sit close together, so you check both and take the higher. A common Morgan that was a $30 collector coin at $20 silver is a metal coin at 2026 silver prices.
The test is three questions. What is melt today? (Weight × purity × spot. A 90% silver Morgan or Peace dollar holds about 0.7734 troy ounces.) What do sold comps say for this date and grade? Which number is higher?
If melt wins, you’re holding bullion, whatever the coin is, and the offer should be a percentage of melt. If comps win by a real margin, you’re holding a collectible, and the offer should be a percentage of retail.
What do dealers pay for bullion and junk silver?
Bullion has the tightest spread in the business. It’s a commodity with a known price, and a shop can resell it in days. These are posted dealer bids from September 2, 2026, when gold closed at $4,336.30 and silver at $63.87, from the Dealer Buy-Rate Sheet that ships with the 2026 Guide, plus ranges from the guide’s July–August 2026 research.
| What you’re selling, and to whom | Typical buy, as a share of the metal |
|---|---|
| American Gold Eagle, 1 oz | 93–99% of spot. National online buyers bid 97–99%; local shops about 95% |
| American Silver Eagle | 84–95% of spot. Best online bids near 95%; local shops about 91% |
| 90% silver dimes, quarters and halves | $30–$42 per $1 face value, or 65–89% of melt. Big lots get the better end; loose handfuls the bottom |
| Gold and silver coins, to a pawn shop | 40–70% of melt |
| Generic gold, consigned to a 22%-buyer’s-premium auction house | Has hammered at 83–86% of melt |
On the other side of the counter, dealers typically retail bullion-related coins at 3–10% over melt. That thin markup is why a fair bullion bid sits so close to the metal value.
How to read a “times face” quote
Shops usually quote junk silver as a multiple of face value: “I’ll do 36× face.” Turn that into a percentage of melt before you answer. Melt for 90% silver is face value × 0.715 × spot, where the 0.715 allows for circulation wear. So divide the multiplier by 0.715 × spot.
At $63.87 silver, the September 2 close, $1 of face holds about $45.67 of melt. An offer of 36× face is about 79% of melt, inside the posted range. An offer of 30× face is about 66%, the bottom of it.
What do dealers pay for collectible coins?
Here the dealer works back from what he can sell the coin for. The ranges below come from the guide’s Dealer Buy-Rate Sheet and its July–August 2026 research.
| Buyer | Typical buy, as a share of retail or market value |
|---|---|
| Local coin shop, collectible coins | 50–70% of retail on posted bids (September 2, 2026). Shops that know the series pay up to 60–80% |
| Local dealer, same-day cash | Roughly Greysheet bid, often 50–70% of retail |
| Any dealer, certified coins | Around 70–80% of current market |
| Specialist rare-coin dealer | Reportedly 75–90% of fair market value |
| Pawn shop | Prices on metal content only, at 40–70% of melt |
Why the spread? Dealers buy at or near Greysheet bid, then retail common certified coins at 20–40% over bid, key dates at 10–25% over and raw coins at 30–60% over. A raw coin carries the widest markup because the dealer is taking the grading risk, so it gets the lowest offer as a share of retail. A slab removes that risk, which is why certified coins land higher.
The spread is not all profit. The guide puts a shop’s net margin at 5–10% after overhead. A dealer offering 50–60% isn’t insulting you. Argue with the number if you have comps. Don’t argue with the model.
Who pays more: a local shop, a coin show or an online sale?
Local coin shop. Same day, no effort. You give up some of the price for speed, and sometimes that’s the right trade. On collectibles, a specialist in your series pays more than a generalist.
Coin show. Fifty dealers pricing independently means the same coin draws different offers thirty feet apart. Walk the whole floor once before you sell anything. If you rent a table and sell to the public, the guide’s advice is to price 10–20% below online comps, because show buyers are there for a discount against the internet.
Selling online yourself. You get closer to retail, minus fees. On a $1,000 shipped sale, the guide’s mid-2026 fee table puts eBay at about 13.7% without a store and about 9.4% with a Basic Store, and Whatnot’s Coins & Money category at about 7.2%. An individual listing costs roughly $8–12 all-in, so coins under about $50 rarely come out ahead.
Consignment. GreatCollections charges a 0% seller’s fee on coins that bring over $1,000, with a 10% buyer’s premium. Keep bullion away from 22%-premium auction houses. A dealer paying close to melt beats a hammer at 83–86% of melt.
One more number. Selling a whole collection to one buyer at once costs 30–50% compared with sending each part to the right venue. That can be a fine choice when time matters more than money, as long as you make it on purpose.
How do you work out a fair offer before you walk in?
- Sort the coin. Bullion, numismatic or overlap, using the melt-versus-comps test above.
- Work out melt. Weight × purity × spot on the day. For a Morgan or Peace dollar that’s 0.7734 oz × spot. For 90% dimes, quarters and halves it’s face × 0.715 × spot.
- Pull retail. Sold comps for that date, in that grade, in that slab. Here’s the four-minute method.
- Apply the range. Multiply melt or retail by the ranges in the tables above for the buyer you’re visiting. That gives you the low and high end of a fair offer.
- Write it down. Walk in with your number on paper.
A worked example at $63.87 silver: a common circulated Morgan holds about $49.40 of melt (0.7734 × $63.87). That’s its floor. If sold comps for your date and grade sit well above it, the coin is a collectible and you’re negotiating against retail. If they don’t, it’s bullion. The guide is blunt about that case: anyone offering 70% of melt on silver dollars, about $35 here, is not making you an offer.
What to say at the counter
- “What would you pay, and how did you get there?” Then listen. An honest offer comes with reasons.
- “What’s your best on these?” The open question works better than naming a number, because the dealer bids against himself. Ask it about a group of coins. Bundling works; grinding on one coin marks you as a nuisance.
- “Recent solds for this in this grade are running $X.” Comps move a dealer. “That seems low” doesn’t.
- For silver: “What’s that per dollar of face, and what spot are you using?” Then do the times-face math.
Bring one representative group, not the whole collection. Close or walk within about five minutes. And treat a free appraisal from someone who also wants to buy as what it is: an offer.
When does a low offer mean the dealer doesn’t want the coin?
Hold the offer up against the ranges above, then work out which kind of low it is.
- Low, but not absurd. A collectible offer under the shop range usually means the coin doesn’t fit that shop. Each shop’s range follows its own customers and expertise, and a generalist pays less for material he can’t move quickly. Show your comps once. If the number doesn’t move, take the coin to a specialist, who reportedly pays 75–90% of fair market value, or to a show.
- Below the metal. On bullion, that isn’t an offer. Pawn shops pay 40–70% of melt because they’re lenders pricing metal, not numismatists. Posted shop bids on junk silver ran 65–89% of melt on September 2, 2026, with the best rates on big lots.
- Low on a raw coin. The dealer is pricing grading risk, and a raw key date is treated as counterfeit until a grading service says otherwise. On a key date that could be worth four figures, grading it first can change the offer completely.
- Low on a cheap coin. On a common coin worth $40 or so, a modest offer reflects handling cost. A dealer buy or a bulk lot is still a sensible exit, because an individual online listing won’t net much more once its $8–12 cost floor comes off.
The best check is a second shop. The gap between two honest offers on the same material is small. The gap between an honest offer and a predatory one is enormous, and two visits show you which one you got.
Questions people also ask
What percentage of melt do coin shops pay for junk silver?
Posted dealer bids on September 2, 2026 ran $30–$42 per $1 face value of pre-1965 90% silver coins, or 65–89% of melt. Bigger lots get better rates. Melt is face value × 0.715 × spot silver.
What percentage of retail does a coin dealer pay?
A local coin shop typically pays 50–70% of retail for collectible coins on posted bids, and up to 60–80% if it knows the series. Certified coins land around 70–80% of current market, specialist rare-coin dealers reportedly pay 75–90% of fair market value, and a same-day cash sale at roughly Greysheet bid often comes in at 50–70% of retail.
How do I turn a “times face” silver offer into a percentage of melt?
Divide the multiplier by the melt in $1 of face value, which is 0.715 × spot silver. At $63.87 silver, the September 2, 2026 close, $1 face of 90% silver holds about $45.67 of melt, so an offer of 36× face is about 79% of melt.
How much do pawn shops pay for gold and silver coins?
Pawn shops pay roughly 40–70% of melt for gold and silver coins and price almost entirely on metal content. A coin with collector value beyond its metal will usually bring more at a coin shop or a specialist dealer.
Is a low offer from a coin dealer an insult?
Usually not. Shops run 5–10% net margins after overhead, so the gap between buy and sell prices is how they stay open. If an offer falls well below the normal range, show sold comps once, then get a second offer from another shop or a specialist.
Keep reading
More answers
- CDN Greysheet: how bid and ask prices are set
- US Coin Shows: Greysheet and dealer pricing (dealer markups over bid and melt)
- Morgan dollar weight and silver content
- eBay selling and store fees
- Whatnot seller fees and commissions schedule
- American Numismatic Association: consumer guidance and dealer directory
- Dealer bids and spot prices: Dealer Buy-Rate Sheet, 2026-09 edition, which ships with the 2026 Guide (dealer boards observed 2 September 2026)
- Shop, pawn-shop and show buy rates, junk-silver melt formula and venue fee table: Buying and Selling Coins: The 2026 Guide, Chapters 3, 11, 19, 29, 32, 36 and 37 (research verified July–August 2026)