About Park Avenue Rarities
Park Avenue Rarities is a coin shop located in Sayville, New York. Collectors visiting this location can find buying, selling, and trading of coin collections, a curated selection of classic US coinage. Park Avenue Rarities is rated by the local collector community, earning 3.2 stars from 24 verified Google reviews. Whether you're searching for gold bullion, classic US type coins, ancient coinage, local coin dealers like Park Avenue Rarities in Sayville are the heart of the New York numismatic community. Call ahead to confirm hours and current inventory before visiting Park Avenue Rarities in Sayville.
Coin Shows coming up in New York
- Coin/Paper and Collectors Show — Oct 17, 2026, Queensbury
- BNA Coin & Currency 3rd Sunday Bourse — Oct 18, 2026, Cheektowaga
Run this shop? Post your appraisal days, buying events, in-store shows and sales here for free. Add an event →
Park Avenue Rarities reviews
Is Park Avenue Rarities well reviewed?
Park Avenue Rarities has a 3.2-star average from 24 Google reviews. Read the reviews on Google Maps →
Frequently asked questions about Park Avenue Rarities
Where is Park Avenue Rarities located?
Park Avenue Rarities is located in Sayville, New York at 173 N Main St suite 232.
Does Park Avenue Rarities buy coin collections?
Yes, Park Avenue Rarities buys, sells, and trades coin collections. Contact the shop for an appraisal or to discuss selling your collection.
What should I expect at Park Avenue Rarities?
Park Avenue Rarities is a local coin shop in Sayville, New York. Expect a curated inventory, knowledgeable staff, and the kind of personal service that the numismatic community relies on.
What other coin shops are near Park Avenue Rarities?
The closest are Long Island Coin in Sayville (0.2 mi), US Coin Depot in Bohemia (2.8 mi), New York Numismatic Group in Bohemia (4.0 mi).
Coin Shops near Park Avenue Rarities
The closest other coin shops to Park Avenue Rarities, by distance: