About Costello's Rare Coins
Costello's Rare Coins is a coin shop located in Halesite, New York. Collectors visiting this location can find buying, selling, and trading of coin collections, a curated selection of classic US coinage, world and foreign coin inventory. Costello's Rare Coins is highly rated by the local collector community, earning 5.0 stars from 9 verified Google reviews. Whether you're searching for gold bullion, classic US type coins, ancient coinage, local coin dealers like Costello's Rare Coins in Halesite are the heart of the New York numismatic community. Call ahead to confirm hours and current inventory before visiting Costello's Rare Coins in Halesite.
Coin Shows coming up in New York
- Coin/Paper and Collectors Show — Oct 17, 2026, Queensbury
- BNA Coin & Currency 3rd Sunday Bourse — Oct 18, 2026, Cheektowaga
Run this shop? Post your appraisal days, buying events, in-store shows and sales here for free. Add an event →
Costello's Rare Coins reviews
Is Costello's Rare Coins well reviewed?
Costello's Rare Coins has a 5.0-star average from 9 Google reviews. With fewer than 10 reviews, the rating can still move a lot. Read the reviews on Google Maps →
Frequently asked questions about Costello's Rare Coins
Where is Costello's Rare Coins located?
Costello's Rare Coins is located in Halesite, New York at 187 Park Ave.
Does Costello's Rare Coins buy coin collections?
Yes, Costello's Rare Coins buys, sells, and trades coin collections. Contact the shop for an appraisal or to discuss selling your collection.
What should I expect at Costello's Rare Coins?
Costello's Rare Coins is a local coin shop in Halesite, New York. Expect a curated inventory, knowledgeable staff, and the kind of personal service that the numismatic community relies on.
What other coin shops are near Costello's Rare Coins?
The closest are Huntington Stamp & Coin in Huntington (4.2 mi), Whitman Coin & Jewelry Inc in Melville (5.0 mi), Numismatic Assets Inc. in Melville (5.8 mi).
Coin Shops near Costello's Rare Coins
The closest other coin shops to Costello's Rare Coins, by distance: